Introduction
Adequate
fluid
intakes must be ensured in stroke
patients at risk of dehydration, especially in the presence of dysphagia and reduced consciousness(1,5) Monitoring and
attempting to stabilize acute physiological
parameters within normal limits such as blood pressure, temperature, hydration
status,
glucose levels and oxygen saturation has become standard
practice for some acute
stroke units(1)
Parenteral fluids may have reduced the occurrence of dehydration and maintained systemic blood pressure after acute stroke.(2) Selection
of initiating solutions during acute phase has been decided arbitrarily owing to the fact that studies of electrolyte
imbalance after stroke are
not extensive, and it remains unclear whether initial
hydration status influences
mortality or functional recovery. As a rule,
rehydration with 5% dextrose or hypotonic solutions during the first hours is
not justifiable since it will readily enter the brain cells resulting in worsening of brain edema. The American
Heart Association has recommended normal saline at 50 ml/hour
during the first hours of acute ischemic
stroke(3).
However, it is not stated clearly when one has to switch to
maintenance solution. Anaerobic metabolism initiated by ischemia induces local lactic acidosis
and elevated tissue PCO2 (not necessarily systemic lactic acidosis)(4).
This fact has caused many authorities to decline the use of lactated Ringer’s
solution as ‘resuscitating ‘ solution
in acute stroke. Secondly, the osmolarity of lactated
Ringer i.e. 273 is considered hypotonic to plasma (normally 285 + 5 mOsm/L).
Since there has been no standard
fluid regimen, neurologists may either use
normal saline, Ringer’s solution or even some doctors use Ringer’s
lactate in spite of the
concern.
The
proponents of Ringer’s solution may either think that the osmolarity of Ringer’s solution
(310 mOsm/L) is ideal in preventing edema , or thought wrongly that Ringer’ solution
is the same as Ringer’s lactate minus lactate.
In fact, their sodium and chloride contents differ
significantly(6).
Glu
|
Electrolyte(mEq/L)
|
|||||||
Product
|
Glu
(g/L)
|
Na+
|
K+
|
Ca++
|
Cl-
|
Lact ate
|
Acet ate
|
(mO
sm/ L)
|
Normal
saline
|
-
|
154
|
-
|
-
|
154
|
-
|
-
|
308
|
Ringer’s
solution
|
-
|
147
|
4
|
4,5
|
155.
5
|
-
|
-
|
310
|
Lactated
Ringer (RL)
|
-
|
130
|
4
|
3
|
109
|
28
|
-
|
273
|
Asering
(acetated
Ringer)
|
-
|
130
|
4
|
3
|
109
|
-
|
28
|
273
|
KAEN 3B
|
27
|
50
|
20
|
-
|
50
|
20
|
-
|
290
|
KAEN 3A
|
27
|
60
|
10
|
-
|
50
|
20
|
-
|
290
|
Within the context
of fluid resuscitation in hypovolemic
shock, the prolonged use of normal saline and Ringer’s solution is associated with
increased risk of
hyperchloremic dilutional acidosis.
In head injuries or subarachnoid hemorrhage, the use of normal saline and
Ringer’s solution may be suitable
in view of high incidence of electrolyte imbalances,
particularly hyponatremia. Any intracranial disease, surgery,
mechanical ventilation and anesthetics may be complicated with electrolyte imbalance. Two distinct
entities exist, namely cerebral
salt wasting and SIADH.
The former is truly sodium depletion and although the clinical picture is similar to latter, this condition
(CSWS) requires different
approach of management by which high sodium infusion solution
is warranted(7) On the contrary SIADH responds merely to fluid restriction
in the region of 600-800 ml/day. However,
this
is not possible in critically ill who may require minimum fluid load more than this to maintain cerebral perfusion pressure.
These two conditions are the suitable
indications for normal saline and Ringer solution.
However, it remains to be questionable if normal
saline or Ringer’s
solution are suitable
as maintenance solution in acute ischemic stroke. One should also consider
that spurious hyponatremia may be caused by tremendous
hyperglycemic response during
acute phase.
Each 100 mg/dl increase
of glucose concentration
is associated with reduction
of 1.7 mEq/L of sodium. In addition, plasma osmolarity is also important
factor.
One recent study has shown that the raised
plasma osmolarity during admission
is associated with stroke
mortality. Plasma osmolarity >296 is considered indicative of hyperosmolar state. This study however did
not show the influence of intravenous rehydration, unlike beneficial oral rehydration
on clinical outcome(2) (note: type of infusion solution was not mentioned explicitly).
Ringer’s acetate may be a suitable
alternative to normal saline and Ringer’s solution.
LR and AR differ only in their bicarbonate
source. LR contains 28 mmol of lactate per liter while AR has 28
mmol of acetate. Unlike lactate the metabolism of which takes place
mostly in the liver, acetate
is metabolized mainly in muscles
and to a lesser extent in kidneys and heart. Acetate Ringer’s
solution has become a standard
resuscitation fluid in pediatric diabetic ketoacidosis,
and proved to be a better intraoperative
solution than LR in maintaining core temperature during iso- and sevofluran anesthesia(8,9,10) .
The issue of osmolarity can be solved by addition of 20% or 40%
magnesium sulphate. For example, to render the osmolarity of Ringer’s acetate to 290, add 10 ml of 20% MgSO4. Administration of MgSO4
is at least safe in stroke patients.(11)
Current
Osmolarity of Asering (Ringer’s acetate)
|
Desired
osmola- rity
|
ml of 20% MgSO4 to be added
|
Mg
(mEq
/cc)
|
Magnesium
(total)
|
273.4
273.4
273.4
273.4
|
285
290
295
300
|
7.25
10.375
13.5
16.625
|
1.66 mEq/ cc
|
12 mEq
17 mEq
22.41 mEq
27.5 mEq
|
Once the hemodynamic condition has been stabilized,
maintenance fluid therapy can be given as KAEN 3B/KAEN 3A. These two solutions may offer advantages
in hypertonic dehydration as well as providing
daily homeostasis requirement of potassium and sodium.
There has been increasing evidence a high potassium intake caused a large reduction in deaths from stroke
even when blood pressure was precisely matched between those on the high and low potassium intakes(12).
CONCLUSION:
Neurologists should not underestimate the importance of hydration status of stroke patients. One particular theme that has emerged from stroke unit trials is that there are differences in the way acute physiology
(such as temperature, blood pressure, blood glucose
and hydration) are managed
between these units and nonstroke units.
There are different
approaches of rehydrating patients with ischemic stroke from those with SAH, head injuries or neurosurgeries.
Timing and selection of parenteral fluids may need to be revisited. One good candidate
for initiating solution in
acute ischemic stroke is Ringer’s
acetate. Unlike normal saline or Ringer solution,
it is not associated with increased risk of hyperchloremic dilutional acidosis when given aggressively in correcting dehydration and shock.
Secondly, it does not interfere
with the interpretation of focal (tissue) lactic acidosis. Should there be a desire to approximate the osmolarity of Ringer’s acetate to that of
plasma, addition of 20% magnesium sulfate is enabled in view of its established safety, while there is now
ongoing large scale efficacy study
involving 712 patients. Following acute phase of stroke, maintenance solution can be considered to
keep the electrolyte
homeostasis, particularly potassium and sodium.
REFERENCES
- Bhalla A, Wolfe CD, Rudd AG. management of acute physiological parameters after stroke. QJM 200 Mar;94(3):167-72.
- Bhalla A. et al. Influence of Raised Plasma Osmolality on clinical outcome after acute stroke. Stroke. 2000;31:2043- 2048
- Adams HP et al. Guidelines for the Early Management of Adults With Ischemic Stroke Stroke 2007, 38:1655-1711
- William E. Hoffman, Fady T. Charbel,, Guy Edelman, James I. Ausman, Brain tissue acid-base changes during ischemia Neurosurgical Focus 2(5): Article 2, 1997
- Whelan K. Inadequate fluid intakes in dysphagic acute stroke.Clin Nutr 2001 Oct;20(5):423-8
- Pedoman Cairan Infus PT Otsuka Indonesia 2000
- Springate J. Cerebral Salt-Wasting Syndrome. eMedicine Journal, may 2, 2001 Vol 2 No 5
- Darmawan I. Ringer’s acetate solution in clinical practice. Medimedia 1999
- Kashimoto S. Comparative effects of Ringer’s acetate and lactate solutions on intraoperative central and peripheral temperatures. J Clin Anesth1998;10(1):23-27
- Mark A Graber. Terapi Cairan, Elektrolit dan Metabolik. Farmedia. Edisi 3, 2010
- Keith W. Muir, Keneddy R. Lees. Dose Optimization of Intravenous Magnesium Sulfate. (stroke.1998;29:918- 923).
- Feng J He, Graham A MacGregor, Beneficial effects of potassium BMJ 2001;323:497-501 ( 1 September )